Robustness of precipitation Emergent Constraints in CMIP6 models

An Emergent Constraint (EC) is a physically-explainable relationship between model simulations of a past climate variable (predictor) and projections of a future climate variable (predictand). If a significant correlation exists between the predictand and the predictor, observations of the latter can be used to constrain model projections of the former and to narrow their uncertainties. In the present study, the EC technique has been applied to the analysis of precipitation, one of the variables most affected by model uncertainties and still insufficiently analysed in the context of ECs, particularly for the recent CMIP6 model ensemble. The main challenge in determining an EC is establishing if the relationship found is physically meaningful and robust to the composition of the model ensemble. Four precipitation ECs already documented in the literature and so far tested only with CMIP3/CMIP5, three of them involving the analysis of extreme precipitation, have been reconsidered in this paper. Their existence and robustness are evaluated using different subsets of CMIP5 and CMIP6 models, verifying if the EC is still present in the most recent ensemble and assessing its sensitivity to the detailed ensemble composition. Most ECs considered do not pass this test: we found one EC not to be robust in both CMIP5 and CMIP6, other two exist and are robust in CMIP5 but not in CMIP6, and only one is verified and is robust in both model ensembles.